I think you misunderstood my comments. Not surprising, because I did not really explain anything.Manhattan Glutton wrote:I'm starting to get annoyed at the anti-pop bias around here. Just because I make a song that some people might enjoy on the first listen, holy shit, I'm a fucking witch! Burn him alive! It's not like you can say, "Gee whiz, this song has no technical merits." Nope, the sole problem you find with the song is you like it on the first listen. Holy fucking Christ! I have sinned against one of Song Fight's unspoken rules! I must make terrible music that requires 500 forced listens otherwise I'm not a musician. Go fuck yourself, Caravan Ray. But we're still cool.Caravan Ray wrote:Manhattan Glutton: This sounds like the feel good hit of summer that you like for the first 20 or so listens then would rather stick a fork in your eye than hear again. Luckily for you, I scored it after 3 listens.
I liked your song very much. I have no anti-pop bias. Catchy pop songs are my favourite things and yours was very good one. This is why I rated it quite highly. When I wrote "feel good hit of the summer" - that was not meant in a derogatory way. I like feel good hits of the summer
As a random observation however, I did notice that it does however have a very catchy but repetitive chorus - the type which can sometimes get annoying after constant listening (note 'sometimes' - only time will tell if yours does this). A very catchy but repetitive chorus is not always a bad thing. But it can sometimes be
I will go fuck myself now....just waiting for the champagne to chill.