Page 1 of 1

I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Fri Jun 08, 2018 1:55 pm
by Pigfarmer Jr
Just kidding... I'll kick you, instead. Okay, still just kidding. But it'd be nice if you'd do some reviews.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Mon Jun 11, 2018 8:33 pm
by Lunkhead
Songs posted.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Tue Jun 12, 2018 1:10 am
by vowlvom
shrts - I'm listening at work and somehow I got interrupted with a question and had to pause this midway through my first listen. Quite impressive for a 35 second song. But yeah, it's short, and it rocks.

add - this is a really great bit of indie rock with some good hooks. Love the handclaps. Guitar solo is a bit over-extended maybe, but I really enjoyed this.

Gilmore Lynett Tootle - haha, this really caught me by surprise. I didn't think I'd be into it from the first few seconds but that genre shift definitely got me on board, and I love your take on the title.

Third Cat - really like the drums, especially the shifting hihat rhythms, and the jangling guitars with their slightly disco vibe are very cool. The vocal melody is interesting, but a bit too sombre for the vibe of the song or something I think? It doesn't entirely work for me.

add and Gilmore definitely my favourites but enjoyed all four of these.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Tue Jun 12, 2018 7:19 am
by thirdcat
shrts - fun but slight. I like the verse a bit more than the "peace among worlds" refrain.

add - I think I mentioned John Vanderslice last time I reviewed one of your tracks, this one reminds me of him even more. I'm a fan of his stuff so I mean that as a compliment. Lots of cool ideas in here, and the vocals work pretty well with the style.

Gilmore Lynett Tootle - Pretty awesome headfake with the guy & guitar intro. Love the way it starts distorting and turns into this totally different electro vibe. Probably my favorite.

Third Cat - Me. I liked my instrumental alright; but couldn't really get the vocals to work and ran out of time.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Tue Jun 12, 2018 3:45 pm
by Pigfarmer Jr
add - I got like a Tom Petty on speed vibe on the chorus vocal. Which is was a totally cool perspective. I liked the music and the melody and the vocal was competently done. I liked the guitar solo going into the combination of vox/gutiar. That was cool. But honestly, you could have ended this at like 2:41 and it'd have been great for me.

Gilmore Lynett Tootle - I'm really proud of this one and owe a huge debt thankfulness to my collaborator.

shrts - I like the guitars and the energy/drive of the song. I, too, liked the non chorus bit better than the title lines, but I think they work fine. It's too short for my taste, but it's cool what you did here. Get in. Rock. Get out.

Third Cat - I like the guitars. Good use of space and sparseness that works very well for me. The beat was a little distracting on the first listen but I enjoyed it on subsequent listens. I was drawn to the lead bit of an outro on the first listen and actually wish that had gone on for at least a few seconds more with a nice, slow fade.

Damn good fight. Not a bad song or recording in the bunch.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Tue Jun 12, 2018 7:51 pm
by Lunkhead
Late entry from Berkeley Social Scene added.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Sat Jun 16, 2018 5:22 am
by Pigfarmer Jr
BSS - I like the guitars and the melody. That's a nice melodic guitar break that might be just a bit too loud int he mix. The vocals took me out of it, especially at the beginning. I do like the attitude in the delivery, especially when the drawn out syllables are a consistent pitch. Overall, I like the combination of relaxed music and a kind of in your face vocal delivery.

Re: I'll Punch You If You Don't Support (Peace Among Worlds Reviews)

Posted: Tue Jun 19, 2018 11:29 am
by BoffoYux


I did a SongFight LP in between Nur Ein plays last night. Starts at 50m14s




https://youtu.be/SvMl8DzvGbE?t=50m14s